Costco Picanha – Meat Lover’s Delight

I remember the first time I stumbled upon a Picanha at a local Brazilian steakhouse. The waiter, seeing my curious gaze, recommended it with such passion that I simply couldn’t resist. And oh boy, was it a revelation!

That juicy, tender meat with a crispy fat cap was unlike anything I’d tasted before.  Since then, I’ve been on a quest to recreate that magic at home. And guess where I found my go-to source for quality Picanha? Costco! Let’s explore everything you need to know about Costco’s Picanha.

Is Picanha From Costco Good Quality?

Is Picanha From Costco Good Quality?

When cooking a luxurious meat like picanha, the quality can significantly influence the overall taste and texture. Costco’s picanha has been found to be of good-to-great quality.

These cuts are typically USDA prime grade, boasting solid marbling and an intact fat cap, which adds to its deliciousness. Even the choice-graded picanhas offer good value.

Be cautious as Costco sometimes offers this meat in vacuum-sealed bags without the fat cap, labeled as “Top Sirloin“. While this is suitable for stews or stir-fries, for roasting or smoking, you’d want the fat cap intact. If you can’t find any, don’t hesitate to ask the Costco butchers.

How Much Does It Cost?

As of the last update, Costco’s picanha (with the fat cap) costs between $6.99 to $8.49 per pound.

Comparatively, Meat N’ Bone offers it at $15.33 – $23 per pound, and local butchers price it between $16 – 20 per pound. This comparison reveals that Costco not only provides top-quality meat but also beats most competitors in pricing.

However, prices might vary based on your location, the season, and local supply.

How to Choose the Best Picanha?

How to Choose the Best Picanha?

When shopping for Picanha, especially at a place as vast as Costco, it’s essential to know what to look for to ensure you’re getting the best cut. Here’s a guide to help you make the right choice.

Weight & Size

The weight and size of your meat can significantly influence the outcome of your dish. While a smaller picanha might seem ideal for fewer servings, they tend to cook faster and can dry out, becoming tough.

A good-sized picanha typically weighs between 3-4 pounds and has an even thickness throughout. If you’re planning a feast, ensure you prepare at least half to a full pound of raw meat per person, considering it shrinks about 10-20% during cooking.


Costco’s picanha comes in three main USDA-certified grades, indicating the meat’s quality. These are:

  • Select: The lowest grade.
  • Choice: The standard grade.
  • Prime: The highest quality.

While there are grades lower than Select, they’re typically used in ground beef. The grade directly correlates with the beef’s marbling, quality, and overall condition. Knowing the grade helps you understand the quality you’re getting for the price.


Freshness can make or break the quality of your dish. While it’s essential to choose meat well within its expiry limit, those with a later expiry date are generally fresher. Fresh meats have a firmer texture and a deeper red hue.

Ensure you pick one that gives you ample time to prepare and cook your meat before it nears the expiry date.

And if you’re curious about other cuts, you might want to check out how Costco’s brisket fares in terms of quality.

The Importance of the Fat Cap

The Importance of the Fat Cap

The fat cap is a defining feature of the picanha. It’s not just about the aesthetics; this layer of fat plays a crucial role in the cooking and flavoring process.  This layer of fat enriches the meat, ensuring it remains moist during cooking.

Moreover, it imparts a unique flavor that many consider the highlight of the dish. In essence, without the fat cap, you’re merely dealing with a top sirloin.

How to Prepare It?

While the fat cap is essential, it’s crucial to prepare it correctly. When getting your meat ready for cooking, you can trim the fat cap to ensure evenness. However, aim to leave about ½ an inch to 1 full inch of fat across the entire cap.

This thickness is the secret to achieving the perfect picanha.

How to Cook Costco Picanha?

After understanding the quality, price, and selection criteria, it’s time to discuss the most exciting part: cooking the meat.


For those who love a smoky flavor, smoking the picanha is the way to go. Trim the fat cap to about ½ an inch and season generously with your preferred rub. Smoke it over charcoal at 275°F using hickory wood for about 2 hours.

Aim for an internal temperature of 145°F for a medium finish. The result? Tender, juicy meat crowned with a delicious fatty cap.

Oven Roasting

If smoking isn’t your thing, roasting is a fantastic alternative. Preheat your oven to 300°F – 350°F and roast the meat until it reaches your desired level of doneness. This method is straightforward and yields equally delicious results.

While we’re on the topic of cooking unique cuts, have you ever tried cooking pork neck bones? They might not be as luxurious as picanha, but they sure pack a punch in flavor.”

Tips for Storing and Preservation

Tips for Storing and Preservation

Once you’ve got your hands on a quality piece of picanha, it’s essential to store and preserve it correctly to maintain its freshness.


If you plan to cook the picanha within a few days, refrigerate it. Ensure it’s wrapped in its original packaging or in a vacuum-sealed bag to retain its freshness.

Freezing for Longer Storage

For longer storage, freezing is the best option. Before freezing, ensure the meat is tightly wrapped in plastic wrap and then placed in a freezer bag. This method prevents freezer burn and preserves the meat’s quality.

Serving Suggestions

Serving Suggestions

Picanha is a showstopper on its own, but pairing it with the right sides can elevate your meal.

In Brazil, where this meat is a staple, it’s often served with rice, beans, and farofa (toasted cassava flour). These sides complement the rich flavors of the meat.

For a contemporary twist, consider serving the meat with roasted vegetables, garlic mashed potatoes, or a fresh salad. The key is to balance the richness of the meat with lighter sides.

Fun Fact: Did you know that the term “Picanha” originates from the Brazilian Portuguese word “picana,” which was a pole used by ranchers in the southern parts of Portugal and Spain to herd cattle? This pole would often poke the cattle in the rump area, where the Picanha cut is located. Over time, this prime cut of beef took on the name of the tool that prodded it! So, when you’re savoring a slice of Picanha, you’re also tasting a bit of history. 🥩🐄


FAQs about Costco Picanha

Why Is Picanha Considered a Premium Cut of Beef?

This meat is prized for its tenderness, rich flavor, and the signature fat cap that renders during cooking. This cut comes from the rump cap muscle, which doesn’t do much work, making it incredibly tender.

Its unique combination of texture and taste makes it a favorite among meat enthusiasts.

Can I Marinate the Picanha Before Cooking, or Is It Best Enjoyed with Just Salt and Pepper?

While the meat is traditionally seasoned with just coarse salt in Brazil, you can certainly marinate it if you prefer. However, given its rich flavor, many chefs recommend minimal seasoning to let the natural taste of the meat shine through.

Is There a Specific Knife or Tool Recommended for Slicing Picanha Post-Cooking?

A sharp carving knife is ideal for slicing this meat in particular. Given its tenderness, a sharp knife ensures clean cuts without tearing the meat. Some also prefer knives with a long blade to achieve even slices.

How Does Picanha Compare to Other Cuts Like Ribeye or Sirloin in Terms of Flavor and Texture?

Picanha is often described as having the tenderness of a filet mignon and the robust flavor of a sirloin. While ribeye is known for its marbling and rich flavor, Picanha stands out for its unique combination of a pronounced beefy taste and the melt-in-your-mouth texture, thanks to its fat cap.

I’ve Seen Picanha Labeled as “Top Sirloin Cap” at Some Stores. Are They the Same?

Yes, this meat is often referred to as “Top Sirloin Cap” in English-speaking countries. However, it’s essential to ensure that it comes with a fat cap, which is its defining feature. Without the fat cap, it’s closer to a regular sirloin cut.


After all this talk about Picanha, I’m reminded of a recent barbecue I hosted. As I proudly served my smoked meat, a friend, unfamiliar with this cut, asked, “Why Picanha? Why not the usual steaks?” I simply smiled and said, “Taste it, and you’ll know.”

Moments later, his nod of approval said it all. If you haven’t tried this meat from Costco yet, I highly recommend giving it a shot.